Upsc Materials

A Complete Free Way to Become an IAS

  • Home
  • Prelims
  • Mains
  • Materials
  • Optionals
  • E-Books
  • Test Series
  • Current Affairs
  • Advertise
  • Donate
Neo Stencil
You are here: Home / Fine Editorials / India Canada relations remain frozen in time [IR]

India Canada relations remain frozen in time [IR]

February 27, 2018 By Swamy Vivekananda Leave a Comment

Justin Trudeau’s India visit was sullied by the epic ineptitude driven by his party’s perennially lax attitudes towards Canadian Sikhs sympathetic to the Khalistani cause

All PDF which are provided here are for Education purposes only. Please utilize them for building your knowledge and don't make them Commercial. We request you to respect our Hard Work.

Join Our Telegram Channel

If you are new to UPSC field, We recommend you to know about UPSC Prelims and UPSC Mains and also UPSC Optionals for better Understanding.

Parivarthan IAS

All our Advertisements are Decent ads [we don't compromise in the Quality] and if anyone have any problem with website or advertisements please contact me [email protected]

Prime Minister Narendra Modi with his Canadian counterpart Justin Trudeau. Photo: HT

In November 2012, then Canadian prime minister Stephen Harper made an official six-day visit to India, accompanied by his wife. He was welcomed at the airport by former Indian minister of state for human resource development Shashi Tharoor. Harper’s itinerary included Agra, Bengaluru, Chandigarh and New Delhi with stops at symbolic sites like the Taj Mahal, Keshgarh Sahib Gurudwara in Anandpur and Someshwara Temple in Bengaluru where Harper and his wife garlanded each other with Mysuru jasmine buds, observing thereafter “we have married again”. Between meetings with business and government leaders where the former Canadian prime minister pushed for greater bilateral trade and investment, Harper was admonished by the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government over alleged support from Canadian Sikhs for the establishment of Khalistan. Harper voiced his unequivocal support of “a united India” alongside his contingent that had several ministers of Sikh origin.

Comparing Harper’s visit to that of his successor Justin Trudeau, who has just wrapped his maiden visit as prime minister, one feels a sense of déjà vu. Notwithstanding Trudeau’s personality enlivened through his wardrobe and dancing skills and the mind-boggling incompetence of Canadian officials in extending an invitation to convicted attempted murderer Jaspal Atwal, both visits have been generally comparable in the intent and agenda of the Canadian delegation, the objectives they sought to achieve, largely trade and investment, and the albatross of Sikh separatism that dominated media coverage and public chatter, snuffing out debate on issues where progress can be made like energy, climate change, trade in agricultural commodities and global issues like UN peacekeeping. Unfortunately, the Khalistan issue prevents most analysts from asking necessary questions on the state of the bilateral relationship and whether sufficient space exists for cooperation on pressing issues.

India-Canada relations are strategically thin. Canada has little to offer in terms of assisting India with core strategic objectives that include China, Pakistan, the subcontinent, maritime security in the Indian Ocean rim and beyond. Worse, Canada does not appear interested in engaging on such issues. Some progress was made on civil nuclear trade under Harper but there has been little mention of the issue since. Limited cooperation exists on energy despite Canada’s noted strengths in the area. For all the talk of boosting bilateral investment and trade, businesses in both countries have been sluggish to heed the call. Geography and differences in industrial structures do not necessarily help.

Under Trudeau, trade philosophies diverge with Ottawa’s focus on including issues like indigenous rights and cultural exceptions in trade agreements. But as tempting as it is to blame both governments for not easing existing constraints, it is unclear whether better access to each other’s markets will redound to elevate the broader trading relationship.

Lack of a strategic core and the proclivity of all Canadian political parties to associate with pro-Khalistan elements allows bilateral relations to be easily captured and hijacked by the thorny diaspora issue. To be sure, deeper bilateral engagement on critical issues will not render Sikh separatism any less important for India. But it might not consume the energy of the diplomatic corps and rock the relationship every few years.

Now, the ball is in Ottawa’s court. If anything, a silver lining from Trudeau’s visit is that the Atwal affair has laid bare the open links between the Liberal Party and members of various groups advocating for Khalistan. Reassurances from Canadian prime ministers regarding India’s territorial integrity ring hollow when rhetoric is not backed by actions. Canadian citizens certainly have the right to voice their support for Khalistan but Canadian politicians have a choice when it comes to associating with or endorsing their views. This effort will be hard since Trudeau’s liberals have a crafty opponent to their left—Jagmeet Singh, whose political rise is grounded on righting the wrongs committed against Sikhs in 1984.

Khalistan aside, the final joint statement does indicate that both countries appear keen to expand strategic cooperation on several issues. Negotiations will “intensify” to finalize a Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement and a Bilateral Foreign Investment Promotion and Protection Agreement. Both leaders agreed to expand the scope of the Canada-India Ministerial Energy Dialogue with a particular focus on electricity, energy efficiency and renewables. Efforts will continue on the civil nuclear front. Trudeau affirmed Canada’s support for India’s entry into the Nuclear Suppliers Group. Both countries agreed to expand security cooperation by institutionalizing strategic dialogues at the national security adviser (NSA) and foreign minister levels. Under the Global Skills Strategy, both prime ministers agreed to facilitate the movement of highly skilled individuals from India to Canada. With sustained engagement on these fronts, both Canada and India could augment their importance and value to each other.

Trudeau’s visit has been pilloried in both countries. One can, of course, take umbrage with the range of Indian clothes worn by Trudeau and his family and Trudeau’s bhangra moves at Canada house. Certain excesses could have been prevented had Canadian officials paid more attention to the sensitivities involved. Nonetheless, it is a hallmark of the times we live in that we venerate tweets and hugs more than policy and history. Seen with perspective and context, Trudeau doubled down on the very issues Harper focused on. What sullied the visit was epic ineptitude driven by his party’s perennially lax attitudes towards Canadian Sikhs sympathetic to the Khalistani cause. Going ahead, Ottawa has to emphasize the strategic aspects of the relationship while steering clear of groups which imperil the latter.

Source : Live Mint

Join other Aspirants

Enter your Mail ID and get Access for Everything !

SHARE AND SUPPORT
Twitter Facebook Telegram WhatsApp

Related posts:

  1. Forging a new nuclear deal
  2. India to Bypass Pakistan on Trade Route to Afghanistan by using Chabahar Port
  3. Handbook of India’s International Relations by David Scott
  4. CJI responds to Ravi Shankar Prasad
  5. Labour intensive exports need a policy push
  6. Why the wheels of justice turn ever slower in India
  7. India’s soft power push: just following a fad?
  8. Why India should intervene in Maldives [IR]

Filed Under: Fine Editorials, UPSC Tagged With: Editorials

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Join other Aspirants

Enter your Mail ID and get Access for Everything !

Parivarthan IAS

Recommended Books

Join Us on Facebook

Contribute for UPSC Materials

Recent Posts

  • Vision IAS Prelims 2020 Test 16 With Solutions
  • Forum IAS Prelims 2020 Test 19 With Solutions PDF
  • Forum IAS Mains 2020 Test 7
  • Forum IAS Mains 2020 Test 6
  • GS Score Prelims 2020 Test 13 With Solutions
  • IAS Network Ethics Complete Notes PDF
  • GS Score Prelims 2020 Test 12 With Solutions
  • Shankar IAS Prelims 2020 Test 8 PDF
  • Next IAS Prelims 2020 Test 9 With Solutions
  • Shankar IAS Prelims 2020 Test 7 PDF

Trending

Categories

  • Anthropology Optional
  • ART & CULTURE
  • Audio Lectures
  • Coaching Institute Materials
  • Current Affairs
  • CURRENT AFFAIRS MONTHLY MAGAZINES
  • Cut-Off
  • DOWNLOAD STANDARD EBOOKS
  • ECONOMICS OPTIONAL
  • ECONOMY
  • ENVIRONMENT & ECOLOGY
  • EPW
  • ESSAY
  • Feedback about Institutes
  • Fine Editorials
  • FORESTRY OPTIONAL
  • Frontline
  • GENERAL SCIENCE
  • GEOGRAPHY
  • GEOGRAPHY OPTIONAL
  • GS-1
  • GS-2
  • GS-3
  • GS-4
  • Hindi Medium
  • Hindi Medium Test Series
  • HISTORY
  • HISTORY OPTIONAL
  • IGNOU
  • Important Articles
  • Important News
  • INTERVIEWS
  • MAINS
  • Mains 2016 Test Series
  • Mains 2017 Test Series
  • Mains 2018 Test Series
  • Mains 2019 Test Series
  • Mains 2020 Test Series
  • Mains Test Series
  • MATHEMATICS OPTIONAL
  • Motivation
  • Notifications
  • Optional 2017 Test Series
  • Optional 2018 Test Series
  • Optional 2019 Test Series
  • Optional 2020 Test Series
  • Optional Test Series
  • Other Articles
  • PHILOSOPHY OPTIONAL
  • POLITICAL SCIENCE OPTIONAL
  • POLITY
  • Prelims 2015 Test Series
  • Prelims 2016 Test Series
  • Prelims 2017 Test Series
  • Prelims 2018 Test Series
  • Prelims 2019 Test Series
  • Prelims 2020 Test Series
  • PRELIMS PAPER – 2 (CSAT)
  • PRELIMS PAPER – I (GS)
  • PRELIMS PREVIOUS PAPERS
  • Prelims Test Series
  • Previous Question Papers
  • PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION OPTIONAL
  • Results
  • Society
  • SOCIOLOGY OPTIONAL
  • SSC
  • Tips and Tricks
  • Topper Notes
  • Uncategorized
  • UPSC
  • UPSC Guidance

Archives

  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017

Join other Aspirants

Enter your Mail ID and get Access for Everything !

Copyright © 2019 · About Us · Privacy Policy · Contact Us